Let me start with some caveats:
- I am not a graphic designer, I just play one on the internet
- These designs are quick concepts, not final, I will fix the way the rope hits the letters etc etc
- I don't expect a consensus (smart people rarely agree) and would welcome feedback of all types
- I don't even love all of these concepts
- The covers that are white background aren't translating well to a jpg. But they are book shaped, I promise.
- This book will primarily be sold online so a thumbnail is all folks will really see. Which is the best thumbnail?
- We are trying to differentiate Super Toys from other books about sensory processing because it is primarily a pattern book helping you make things to support sensory processing. The language about the sensory systems supports the patterns, not the other way around. It would be nice if that was somehow communicated on the cover...
- The subtitle (DIY Projects to Support Sensory Processing) is arguably more important than the main title (Super Toys)
- Any feedback is helpful
- Especially something like: "I like #3 except for the font" or "I like the idea of using the chalkboard but not exactly how you have it. How about....." or "don't use the chalkboard, it's confusing to look at" or "here's a completely new and awesome idea you should use"
- If you are an online sort of person, share a link to this post and maybe others will hop over and give their feedback too.
So....what's working here?
PS if you just can't get enough about cover design and want to see how the pros do it, check out this post by Emily Henderson.